Have a tendency to whenever dates are provided, he could be given which have twenty four hours of few days that does not matches thereupon big date because when you look at the genuine history. One such example happens in Harry Potter together with Prisoner off Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney means 16 Oct because the Friday, regardless if 16 October 1993 are a friday.
There are also contradictions inside books of this type. Particularly, from inside the Harry Potter while the Cup off Flame, each other step 1 September and you can 2 September are supplied as the Mondays and you will, into the Harry Potter plus the Prisoner from Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is determined with the 20 April, however, mindful parsing of your own text message demonstrates this may has taken place no later on than simply March.
As well as, for the Harry Potter as well as the Goblet of Flame people say that the Champions was indeed selected for the Monday 30 October, but 30 Oct is actually a tuesday inside 1994.
Inside the a bankruptcy proceeding out of Quidditch From Ages, people say that very first Quidditch World Glass happened for the 1473. In the event your title try kept the four years, this issues towards the statement during the Goblet off Fire that the 1994 Community Cup was the latest 422nd. In the event that Quidditch From Many years is right, the fresh new 422nd Quidditch World Mug carry out in fact fall-in the season 3161, in case Goblet off Flame is useful, the first Business Mug had been held during the 306.
Historical issues [ ]
As the show, according to the timeline produced from the new Chamber out-of Treasures resource, is decided throughout the 1990s, the newest collection tend to seems like it’s set in this new late 1990s to help you middle-2000s, more or less concurrent into publication of your own instructions. Inside the Harry Potter therefore the 50 % of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to mention into the “predecessor” of one’s Perfect Minister of your British. According to the over schedule, this would take place in the summer from 1996, if Best Minister are John Significant, whoever immediate ancestor are a woman (is the reason first interviewing Fudge, the publication states the fresh election, but Significant wasn’t initial decided to go with and simply got more than once Thatcher resigned.
It’s possible, not impractical, you to definitely Fudge might be writing about a more distant ancestor, once the Thatcher took place of work in advance of Fudge allegedly turned Minister having Wonders. (Regardless if one can think a scenario where Fudge try delegated because of the Minister to possess Wonders to get to know to your Finest Minister as he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller workplace.) kissbrides.com check Additionally, brand new character and you may reputation for the prime Minister represented seems to a great deal more directly match compared to Tony Blair than simply regarding John Big. A blog post regarding Every day Send cards one to Rowling are close into the following-Chancellor of Exchequer Gordon Brown (tend to regarded as a competition in order to Blair’s management of Labour Group, exactly who been successful him and you may became Best Minister), and that she has been wanting to let you know Blair’s terrible front side. If the guides was place in sync with guide time from Philosopher’s Stone, then so it knowledge create take place in 2002 (immediately after Blair turned into Finest Minister).
However, it had been later stated that twenty-two November is a saturday, it was a student in 1994
A comparable situation pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was simply said as being 665 in the course of new basic publication, however, Nicolas Flamel try a bona-fide historical figure and would not have reached that years until 1996, within the time the first guide try had written. The rebuttal for this is the fact that the date the “real” Nicolas Flamel came into this world does not communicate with the newest Nicolas Flamel away from Harry Potter.
A separate state can be found away from Rubeus Hagrid’s period given that Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is intended from the show you to Hagrid got one status contained in this a couple of years away from their expulsion off school when you look at the 1942. However in one to world out of Harry Potter plus the Goblet from Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces on Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper frequently overlap which have Molly’s decades in school, it seems impractical one she remembers a previous gamekeeper. not, it will be possible one to Hagrid don’t end up being an excellent gamekeeper instantaneously once being expelled, but rather become while the Ogg’s secretary. This is certainly probable once the whenever Harry believes that he often getting expelled to own flying with the broomstick versus permission in his first year, the guy magic in the event that he’d be permitted to stay on as Hagrid’s assistant.
